| Date | Opponent | Result | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sep. 1 | at Washington & Jefferson | W, 2-1 | |
| Sep. 3 | at Lynchburg | L, 1-7 | |
| Sep. 6 | at Earlham | W, 9-1 | |
| Sep. 9 | RHODES | W, 3-1 | |
| Sep. 16 | WOOSTER | W, 3-0 | |
| Sep. 17 | OBERLIN | W, 4-0 | |
| Sep. 23 | DENISON | L, 2-3 (OT) | |
| Sep. 24 | KENYON | L, 1-5 | |
| Oct. 1 | SEWANEE | W, 6-1 | |
| Oct. 4 | at Ohio Wesleyan | W, 6-1 | |
| Oct. 7 | EARLHAM | W, 3-2 | |
| Oct. 8 | at DePauw | W, 3-0 | |
| Oct. 14 | at Wooster | W, 6-2 | |
| Oct. 15 | at Oberlin | W, 7-1 | |
| Oct. 21 | at Denison | L, 2-7 | |
| Oct. 22 | at Kenyon | L, 1-2 | |
| Oct. 26 | DEPAUW | W, 3-0 | |
| Oct. 28 | OHIO WESLEYAN | W, 6-0 | |
| Nov. 1 | at Kenyon | W, 2-1 | NCAC Semifinals |
| Nov. 4 | at Denison | L, 1-2 | NCAC Final |